🔗 Share this article

Ministers have decided against establishing a public probe into the IRA's 1974-era Birmingham city bar attacks.

This Horrific Incident

Back on 21 November 1974, twenty-one individuals were murdered and two hundred twenty wounded when explosive devices were set off at the Mulberry Bush and Tavern in the Town venues in Birmingham, in an assault largely thought to have been planned by the IRA.

Judicial Fallout

Not a single person has been found guilty over the attacks. Back in 1991, 6 defendants had their sentences overturned after spending more than 16 years in detention in what remains one of the gravest errors of justice in United Kingdom history.

Relatives Fight for Truth

Loved ones have for years pushed for a national inquiry into the attacks to discover what the authorities was aware of at the time of the incident and why no one has been held accountable.

Official Response

The security minister, Dan Jarvis, announced on Thursday that while he had deep compassion for the families, the administration had determined “after careful deliberation” it would not commit to an investigation.

Jarvis said the authorities considers the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery, established to examine deaths associated with the Northern Ireland conflict, could investigate the Birmingham incidents.

Campaigners Respond

Campaigner Julie Hambleton, whose 18-year-old sister Maxine was murdered in the bombings, said the statement indicated “the government are indifferent”.

The 62-year-old has for years campaigned for a public probe and explained she and other grieving relatives had “no plan” of taking part in the commission.

“We see no real autonomy in the body,” she stated, noting it was “tantamount to them assessing their own performance”.

Demands for Document Disclosure

Over the years, grieving loved ones have been calling for the release of documents from security services on the incident – specifically on what the authorities knew before and after the bombing, and what proof there is that could lead to legal action.

“The entire British establishment is resisting our relatives from ever discovering the reality,” she declared. “Exclusively a legally mandated judge-led national investigation will provide us access to the documents they state they do not possess.”

Legal Authority

A statutory public probe has distinct legal authorities, such as the authority to oblige witnesses to appear and reveal details related to the investigation.

Prior Inquest

An hearing in 2019 – campaigned for grieving relatives – ruled the those killed were murdered by the Provisional IRA but did not determine the identities of those responsible.

Hambleton commented: “The security services told the then coroner that they have no documents or documentation on what remains England’s most prolonged unresolved mass murder of the last century, but at present they want to pressure us to engage of this investigative body to share evidence that they assert has not been present”.

Official Criticism

Liam Byrne, the Member of Parliament for the Birmingham area, characterized the administration's ruling as “profoundly disappointing”.

In a announcement on Twitter, Byrne wrote: “Following so much time, such immense grief, and numerous failures” the loved ones are entitled to a procedure that is “impartial, judicially directed, with complete capabilities and unafraid in the search for the facts.”

Continuing Grief

Discussing the family’s persistent pain, Hambleton, who leads the Justice 4 the 21, stated: “No family of any horror of any sort will ever have resolution. It doesn’t exist. The pain and the grief persist.”